There are many different methods for breaking in a softball glove, each with its pros and cons. We suggest checking with the manufacturer of your glove to see what they suggest as gloves made from different types and grades of leather may have different recommendations.

The two basic goals of breaking in a glove are to soften the leather and create a pocket in the glove. No matter what you do, most will agree that the most effective way to break in a new glove is to use it!

Softening the Leather

There are a number of different oils and lotions that can be used to soften the leather on your glove. Our preferred product is Nokona’s NLT Classic Glove Conditioner (available at Jonquil Sporting Goods.) The following products are also good for this purpose:

• Vaseline
• Saddle Soap
• Other Manufacturer’s Solutions
• Mink Oil or Neatsfoot Oil
• Tanners Glove Oil
• “Hot Glove” Treatment. This treatment consists of putting a special foam on your glove and then baking it in your oven for 4 minutes. This method is very controversial – some swear by it, others call it harmful to the glove.

Remember, when softening the leather, more oil / soap / cream is NOT better!! Use the oil in small amounts and wipe it around your glove-don’t slop it on and allow it to soak in – this will make the leather deteriorate faster.

Forming the Pocket

Besides actually playing catch or spending your afternoons throwing a ball into your glove, there are a number of ways to form a pocket in your glove. The most popular method is to place a softball in the pocket and tie the glove shut with shoelaces, string, or a belt. There are also several products that are designed to hold the softball glove shut and in the proper position while not in use.